Journal of the ...Volume 12 Issue 3 Philosophy in p...
Normal View Dyslexic View

Commentary

Philosophy in prison

M.M. McCabe*†email-imageM.M. McCabe*††

Mary Margaret McCabe (‘MM’) works on ancient philosophy, on ethics and on the philosophy of medicine; she has published mostly on Plato, but also on the Presocratics, on Aristotle and on the Stoics, as well as on topics in contemporary ethics and medicine. She was Professor of Ancient Philosophy at King’s College London from 1998 to her retirement in 2014, and thereafter Professor of Philosophy Emerita. She is a Fellow of the British Academy and was President of the British Philosophical Association (2008–12), of the Mind Association (2016–17), and of the Aristotelian Society (2022-23). She is Chair of Trustees of the charity Philosophy in Prison.

email-image mm.mccabe@kcl.ac.uk

Abstract

The UK prison system is in crisis: overcrowded, understaffed, ill fitted to whatever purpose imprisonment might be intended to have. Prison education is particularly under pressure, especially since a majority of prisoners are functionally illiterate. The charity Philosophy in Prison seeks to address the complex problems of prison education by offering philosophical conversations in prisons: oral, so accessible to most, but driven by difficult philosophical questions that are puzzling to anyone. This process faces down the disadvantage suffered by many within the criminal justice system, that their voices are not heard (the problem of epistemic injustice). For these conversations have an equalising effect, since the problems they address are puzzling to anyone, whether new to it or expert. That general puzzlement allows the participant both to see the viewpoints of others, and to have their own viewpoint seen by others. This matters: it shows each prisoner that they do have standing, in themselves, after all. (This article is published in the thematic collection ‘The arts and humanities: rethinking value for today—views from Fellows of the British Academy’, edited by Isobel Armstrong.)

Keywords

UK prison systemprison educationphilosophy in Prisonphilosophical conversationepistemic injusticeequalising effect
Download PDF
Cite
Published on: 17 September 2024
Volume: 12
Issue: Issue 3
Article ID: a41
Article view count: 131
Article download count: 0
Copyright statement
© The author(s) 2024. This is an open access article licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 4.0 International License
Cite this article
McCabe, M.M. (2024), ‘Philosophy in prison’, Journal of the British Academy, 12(3): a41 https://doi.org/10.5871/jba/012.a41

Related Articles

Default cover image
Trusting the permanence of self for people with Alzheimer’s disease

Gloria Frisone

Although informed consent is rooted in the growing affirmation of the subject’s autonomy, medical anthropology has highlighted the inherent limits of this procedural notion. My ethnographic research in neurological and geriatric clinics between France and Italy showed the triangular (dis)trust relationship—between older people with Alzheimer’s disease (AD), their doctor, and their caregiver. Following their cognitive decline and loss of autonomy, people with Alzheimer’s disease (AD) could be victims of epistemic injustice in two specific moments of the illness: the diagnostic disclosure and the institution of legal protection. If the diagnostic information diminishes the patient’s credibility, the institution of legal protection undermines the patient’s social identity and legal status. However, when caregivers preserve an unconditional trust in the permanence of the patient’s subjective identity, this trust may be conveyed to clinical teams, significantly improving the therapeutic relationship, the course of the disease, and the quality of life for all the actors involved.

10.5871/jba/011s6.103
19 December 2023

Thematic article

Normal View Dyslexic View

Philosophy in prison

M.M. McCabe*†email-imageM.M. McCabe*††

Mary Margaret McCabe (‘MM’) works on ancient philosophy, on ethics and on the philosophy of medicine; she has published mostly on Plato, but also on the Presocratics, on Aristotle and on the Stoics, as well as on topics in contemporary ethics and medicine. She was Professor of Ancient Philosophy at King’s College London from 1998 to her retirement in 2014, and thereafter Professor of Philosophy Emerita. She is a Fellow of the British Academy and was President of the British Philosophical Association (2008–12), of the Mind Association (2016–17), and of the Aristotelian Society (2022-23). She is Chair of Trustees of the charity Philosophy in Prison.

email-image mm.mccabe@kcl.ac.uk